The Edit — Bedding
Mattress Protectors Compared: SafeRest to AllerEase
5 waterproof mattress protectors ranked by owner rating, all at 4.5 or above. Whether each is truly waterproof is the split that recurs, and only a zippered encasement does what allergists ask of a cover.
This guide is research-led: we have not handled these units ourselves. If you buy through our links we may earn a commission — it never changes a pick. How we choose
The 5 mattress protectors here are ranked by rating, then by how many owners rated them, read on 8 October 2026, as How we choose describes. Each is read against what owners consistently report, and against the Mayo Clinic’s advice for dust mite allergy. Nothing here was handled or tested.
SafeRest Waterproof Queen Size Mattress Protector
Good fit Spills, sweat and a quiet night
Not for A dust mite allergy, which needs an encasement
Linenspa Waterproof Mattress Protector, Fitted Sheet Style
Good fit A thick mattress that needs a deep pocket
Not for A light sleeper bothered by a plastic rustle
PlushDeluxe Bamboo Waterproof Mattress Protector
Good fit A sleeper who wants to forget the protector is there
Not for A hot sleeper, as some owners find it warm
BEDLORE Waterproof Mattress Protector, Noiseless
Good fit A bed that could use a little extra cushion
Not for Frequent hot washing, which some say it did not survive
AllerEase Ultimate Allergy Protection Zippered Mattress Protector
Good fit Dust mite allergy or a bed bug worry
Not for Anyone who dreads wrestling a mattress into a cover
The SafeRest suits most beds
The SafeRest has 280,571 ratings at 4.6, far more than any other protector here. Owners like the fit, the softness and that it makes no noise, which is the complaint that sinks cheaper waterproof covers.
SafeRest Waterproof Queen Size Mattress Protector
280,571 ratings at 4.6, the most rated here, a fitted protector owners call quiet and soft.
Current price shown on Amazon. We may earn a commission.
| Style | Fitted, waterproof |
|---|---|
| Size read | Queen |
280,571 ratings at 4.6. Owners say it is comfortable, not crunchy and good value, and gives peace of mind. The split is the one every protector here shares: some call it fully waterproof, others say liquid got through.
Buy it if
- Spills, sweat and a quiet night
Don't buy it if
- A dust mite allergy, which needs an encasement
Linenspa fits deep mattresses and stays put
The Linenspa is cut like a fitted sheet, and owners say its deep fit stays in place. It carries 114,615 ratings at 4.6.
Linenspa Waterproof Mattress Protector, Fitted Sheet Style
114,615 ratings at 4.6, a deep-fitting protector that owners say stays in place.
Current price shown on Amazon. We may earn a commission.
| Style | Fitted sheet style |
|---|
114,615 ratings at 4.6. Owners say it protects well against spills and dirt. Noise and water resistance are mixed: some find it silent and waterproof, others hear a plastic rustle or report urine seeping through.
Buy it if
- A thick mattress that needs a deep pocket
Don't buy it if
- A light sleeper bothered by a plastic rustle
PlushDeluxe bamboo feels like no protector at all
The PlushDeluxe has a top of viscose derived from bamboo. Owners say it does not change how the bed feels, and some compare it to sleeping on a marshmallow. It carries 43,427 ratings at 4.6.
PlushDeluxe Bamboo Waterproof Mattress Protector
43,427 ratings at 4.6, a bamboo-viscose top that owners say does not change how the bed feels.
Current price shown on Amazon. We may earn a commission.
| Top | Bamboo-derived viscose |
|---|
43,427 ratings at 4.6. Owners praise the softness, the fit and the lack of crinkle. Temperature splits them: some say it sleeps cool, others find it very hot.
Buy it if
- A sleeper who wants to forget the protector is there
Don't buy it if
- A hot sleeper, as some owners find it warm
BEDLORE adds a little cushion
BEDLORE was 18th in Amazon’s Home & Kitchen Best Sellers on 8 October 2026. Owners like its soft backing, which they say adds a light cushion and makes an old mattress look new.
BEDLORE Waterproof Mattress Protector, Noiseless
27,482 ratings at 4.6, a protector with a soft backing owners describe as a light cushion.
Current price shown on Amazon. We may earn a commission.
| Style | Fitted, waterproof |
|---|
27,482 ratings at 4.6. Owners say it is comfortable and protects against spills. Durability in the wash splits them: some say it holds up, others that it ripped.
Buy it if
- A bed that could use a little extra cushion
Don't buy it if
- Frequent hot washing, which some say it did not survive
For dust mites, buy a zippered encasement
A fitted protector covers the top and sides of a mattress and leaves the underside open. For dust mite allergy, the Mayo Clinic asks for more than that.
The AllerEase zips closed around the whole mattress, which is the encasement that advice describes.
AllerEase Ultimate Allergy Protection Zippered Mattress Protector
3,444 ratings at 4.5, a zippered encasement owners rate for allergies and bed bugs.
Current price shown on Amazon. We may earn a commission.
| Style | Zippered encasement |
|---|
3,444 ratings at 4.5. Owners say it works against allergies and bed bugs and stays in place. Getting it on splits them, and durability is mixed: some say it holds up with pets, others that it fell apart after 2 washes.
Buy it if
- Dust mite allergy or a bed bug worry
Don't buy it if
- Anyone who dreads wrestling a mattress into a cover
To make an old mattress softer rather than cleaner, mattress toppers, compared ranks the toppers, and sheet sets, compared covers what goes on top.